Five Dealers Turning Google Business Profiles Into Showroom Traffic

Doug Karr November 19, 2026

For a lot of car shoppers, the first thing they see from your dealership isn’t your website. It’s your Google Business Profile: the listing with your hours, your photos, your reviews and the buttons to call, get directions or visit your site.

Five Overfuel dealers grew those Google interactions by 35% to 78% from May through September 2026, compared with the same months in 2025. That stands out: across 135 Overfuel customers with established Google profiles, the median saw interactions fall 7% over the same period, and only 38% grew at all. They range from a six-rooftop group in metro Phoenix to a single lot in a small Idaho town. Here’s what their numbers look like, and what they have in common.

Bar chart of the change in Google Business Profile calls, direction requests and website clicks, May–September 2026 vs. 2025: Huntsman Wholesale +78%, Auto Fanatics +71%, Harvest Auto Family +69%, Taylor Automotive +66%, Ideal Cars +35%, and the median Overfuel customer −7%.
Google Business Profile Performance data, Overfuel data warehouse · same profiles May–Sep 2026 vs. 2025 · Ideal Cars = 5 of 6 profiles · median across 135 customers with 500+ interactions in May–Sep 2025

Why Your Google Profile Matters

Google counts three kinds of interactions on a Business Profile: phone calls, direction requests and website clicks. Each one is a shopper raising their hand. Someone tapping “Directions” is planning a visit. Someone tapping “Call” wants an answer now.

The traffic that comes through is also some of the best a dealer site gets. At all five dealers below, Google profile visitors converted to leads at or above the site-wide rate. At three of them, it was two to more than three times the rate.

Chart of website lead conversion rates, May 1–September 30, 2026, for visitors from the Google profile versus the site average: Auto Fanatics 5.2% vs. 1.5%, Ideal Cars 7.1% vs. 3.4%, Huntsman Wholesale 2.7% vs. 1.3%.
Overfuel first-party site analytics · May 1–Sep 30, 2026 · form and call leads · Google profile visits = visits classified as “google business profile”
DealerProfiles comparedMay–Sep 2025 interactionsMay–Sep 2026 interactionsChange
Huntsman Wholesale (Melba, ID)12,8525,081+78%
Auto Fanatics (Fredericksburg, VA)13,4965,987+71%
Harvest Auto Family (Wahoo, NE)15,2418,883+69%
Taylor Automotive (Martin, TN)14,8318,037+66%
Ideal Cars (Mesa, AZ)5 of 616,31022,023+35%

Ideal Cars: Six Rooftops, One Playbook

Ideal Cars is a six-rooftop independent group in metro Phoenix. It launched its Overfuel website in April 2026, and inventory auto-posts and Directory Listings went live on all six Google profiles the next day. Since then, the group has published 1,803 inventory posts, about 270 a month, with no staff time spent posting.

Across the five profiles with 2025 history, direction requests rose 36%. The biggest gains came at East Mesa (Hill), up 77% in total interactions, followed by Apache Junction (+58%) and Crismon Rd. (+44%).

Google profile metric (5 profiles)May–Sep 2025May–Sep 2026Change
Direction requests3,6815,011+36%
Website clicks11,64314,977+29%
Calls2,4053,017+25%

On the website, visitors arriving from Google converted at 7.1%, roughly double the 3.4% site average. That added up to 736 leads from 10,369 Google profile visits.

Huntsman Wholesale: Small Town, Big Jump

You don’t need a big market to win on Google. Huntsman Wholesale is a single-rooftop independent in Melba, Idaho, and its Google profile interactions grew 78% in its first summer on Overfuel, the fastest growth of these five dealers.

Huntsman launched its Overfuel website at the end of April 2026. Auto-posts started May 1 and Directory Listings followed later that month. It has published 151 inventory posts so far, about 25 a month. The momentum is still building: over the most recent 90 days, interactions ran 95% ahead of 2025.

Google profile metricMay–Sep 2025May–Sep 2026Change
Direction requests372675+81%
Website clicks2,6114,493+72%
Calls136157+15%

Google visitors converted at 2.7% on the Huntsman site, twice the 1.3% site average, for 90 leads from 3,371 visits.

Auto Fanatics: Google Visitors Who Buy

More interactions are good. Better ones are what move cars. At Auto Fanatics, an independent dealer in Fredericksburg, Virginia, Google profile visitors are the best-converting traffic on the site: 5.2%, against 1.5% site-wide. That’s 3.3 times the average, and 211 leads from 4,097 visits.

Auto Fanatics was already an Overfuel website customer before 2025. It added Directory Listings in August 2025 and inventory auto-posts in January 2026, and has published 276 posts since, about 34 a month. All three interaction types grew by more than half.

Google profile metricMay–Sep 2025May–Sep 2026Change
Website clicks2,7264,559+67%
Calls245385+57%
Direction requests8571,318+54%

Harvest Auto Family: A Steady Climb

Harvest Auto Family, in Wahoo, Nebraska, shows what a step change looks like when it sticks. Website clicks from its Google profile ran about 1,000 a month through February 2026. Starting in March, they jumped to between 1,450 and 1,640 a month, and they have held there since.

Harvest’s path was gradual: an Overfuel website in August 2025, Directory Listings the next day, then inventory auto-posts in January 2026. It has published 389 posts so far, about 46 a month.

Google profile metricMay–Sep 2025May–Sep 2026Change
Website clicks4,5227,834+73%
Calls265355+34%
Direction requests8471,050+24%

The Google profile now brings in 13% of Harvest’s site visits and 14% of its leads: 130 of 940 from May through September.

Taylor Automotive: The Phone Rings More

In Martin, Tennessee, Taylor Automotive’s Google profile works like a call engine. Calls from the profile rose 89%, to about 375 a month. Calls now make up 22% of Taylor’s profile interactions, more than twice the 9% typical across Overfuel dealers.

Taylor has been an Overfuel website customer since before 2025 and added inventory auto-posts in April 2026, publishing 242 posts so far, about 31 a month.

Google profile metricMay–Sep 2025May–Sep 2026Change
Calls9641,824+89%
Website clicks3,7315,985+60%
Direction requests556612+10%

The profile is now Taylor’s second-largest source of website traffic. It drove 26% of site visits and 37% of all leads (79 of 214), a sign that shoppers who find Taylor on Google arrive ready to talk.

What These Dealers Have in Common

These are five different markets and five different stories, but a few patterns show up in every one.

  • Their profiles stay fresh. Every dealer here publishes inventory to Google automatically, from about 25 to 270 posts a month, without anyone on staff remembering to do it.
  • The website finishes the job. A Google click only matters if the site turns it into a lead. Google visitors converted at or above the site average at all five dealers, and at two to three times the average at three of them.
  • Their growth has held. This isn’t one lucky month. All five are up for the full May–September window and over the most recent 90 days, and three are growing faster lately than over the summer as a whole.

Results vary by market, inventory and the work each dealership puts in. But these five show what a well-run Google profile, backed by a site built to convert, can look like.

Download the Case Study

See What Your Google Profile Could Be Doing

Overfuel websites come with automated inventory posting to Google Business Profile and Directory Listings management, all tied into first-party analytics, so you can see exactly what Google is sending you and how it converts. Talk to our team to see how your profile stacks up.

About the numbers: Google interactions are calls, direction requests and website clicks from Google Business Profile Performance data, comparing May–September 2026 with the same profiles in May–September 2025. Website visits, conversion rates and leads (form and call leads) come from Overfuel’s first-party site analytics for May 1 to September 30, 2026. Results reflect these dealers’ performance since launching on Overfuel and are not a guarantee of future results.

By Doug Karr

Doug is the Local Presence Engineer at Overfuel, where he drives platform and service innovation to help retail auto dealerships achieve maximum ROI through SEO, paid media, and omnichannel marketing strategies. He leads the integration of agentic and generative AI into Overfuel’s solutions, optimizing both client campaigns and internal operations. With a focus on high-conversion acquisition and local visibility, Doug is dedicated to driving Overfuel's position in the industry as go-to growth partner for independent dealers, groups, and OEM-aligned networks.